Skip to main content

Keynes vs Minsky

I am a beginner in economics but reading Positive Money book 'Modernising Money' by Ben Dyson and Andrew Jackson. My interest grew in the work of Minsky and encouraged me to read more about Keynes.

Keynes economics promote the view that in the long run economics system converge into an equilibrium with the support of the government. Nevertheless you cannot help the role of banks in the system and wonder after reading the following quote:

“But this long run is a misleading guide to current affairs. In the long run we are all dead. Economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task if in tempestuous seasons they can only tell us that when the storm is long past the ocean is flat again.” (Keynes, 1923)

This imply that economists did not comprehend why we had a financial crisis and collapse. Minsky with  his model 'Financial Instability Hypothesis' strive to answer this question. The idea in Minsky's work in a 'simplistic summary is that in very good environments economic decision will be made with an overconfidence of financial stability. Ultimately it motivate excess leverage that advance farther than a stable economy' (Coates, 2009)

We could summarize the whole in three words 

'STABILITY IS DESTABILISING'

Some links:
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

People & Money – The real problem is to not act

A quick extract of an article I wrote after an event I've organised in Leicester with the support of Positive Money and Transition Leicester.  You can access the full article on  Positive Money Blog . ''In the last few months, I contemplated the idea of organising an event in Leicester about Money and the financial system. I first started by looking for a supportive group of individuals to do it with but after few unsuccessful  attempts in recruiting people and ensuring continuous involvement, it became clear that speaking was not enough but that I had to take action. I was letting go of my passive consumer shield to be more of an active citizen. With the full support of Transition Leicester and Positive Money, 5 knowledgeable key speakers were invited. 40 people managed to attend the event. Food, hot and cold drinks were available for everyone to share. The evening turned out not only to be fun and interesting but also educating. This was a moment we travelled in a l...
Post a Comment
Read more

C'est triste et c beau en meme temps

Philippe, Popo et Marie Toto sont dans la cuisine. Assise sur une chaise, son carnet sur les genoux, elle le regarde et attends. Elle veux toute son attention.  Il marque le pas dans la cuisine, attrape une pomme et une petite Assiette.  Coupes la pomme,la met dans l'assietre  mange la pomme.  Croise les bras. Se touche le menton. Reflechit. Il s'assoit enfin. Elle repete sa question: Marie Toto: Que voudrais tu?... Philippe: Pour quoi? Pour la fin?  Elle hoche la tete Philippe: mais je ne sais pas. Quel drole daffaire Le silence pese Philippe J'aimerais qu'il fasse beau ce serait bien quand meme Marie Toto A oui ce serait bien mais ca je ne peut pas tassurer qu'il fasse grand soleil Philippe: oui bien sur... Ce serait bien que pierre lise un texte et que to marie, que tu sois ma voix.que tu parle pour moi marie, que tu sois ma voix Marie toto : moi ta voix? Quel voix? Ma voix avec la tienne alors que tu ne sera plus la.. Je ne suis ni actrice ni directr...
Read more